Glass is better than plastic, right?

The awareness of the pollution and contamination to our waterways, and oceans of plastic is not one we can avoid, we must therefore look at alternatives and one choice that seems logical would be that glass. In fact, “Glass bottles could be worse for the environment than plastic, Coca Cola warns(1).

The decision to buy plastic or glass bottles or even water in a can, isn’t as clear cut as it may seem. This is due to the factors that are involved in the whole process, these include material sourcing, manufacturing, transportation, weight, recycling & reuse and end of life disposal. The only option for sustainable and great-tasting water is to use LUQEL’s Water Station that sources all its water from your tap water.

To understand the impact on the environment from the alternatives we need to understand the carbon footprint of the options. Carbon (CO2) footprint is the amount of carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere as a result of the activities of a particular individual, organisation, product or community as defined by the Oxford English dictionary. It is measured by estimating the CO2 emissions that the activity causes, any emissions of other greenhouse gases (methane and nitrous oxide) and in some cases other types of climate impacts as well, such as vapour trails from aeroplanes from transportation. As many of these activities are estimated, results can vary depending on the reporting group.

Calculate the Carbon Footprint

To manufacture 450grams of PET (polyethylene terephthalate) plastic can produce up to 1.36kg of carbon dioxide. The PET then needs to be manufactured, processed, transported which contribute significantly. A 500ml plastic bottle of water has a total carbon footprint equal to on average 82.8grams of CO2 (2). Using the same size comparison this is the average for each material:

 

500 ml

 

Single use
plastic

 

Glass bottle –
single use
Glass bottle –
refill
Aluminium
can 330ml
Average Co2 82.9g 107.7g 8g 113.4g

The UK generates as a country approx. 5 million tonnes of plastic waste each year, including 7.7 billion “single-use” plastic bottles per year. With only 45% of those making it to be recycled, of that 45% only 9% is used for making new plastic bottles.  A proposed Deposit Return Scheme (DRS) has been discussed for England, Wales, and Northern Ireland from 2023, but Scotland will start on 1st July 2022. This will make it easier for everyone to recycle their used bottles and cans, including all drinks sold in PET plastic, metal and glass, but at the moment we have to assume that the figures for recycling are as low as estimated.

FACTORS IN YOUR PURCHASING DECISION

Additional considerations when looking at the impact of each material also include

Transportation – moving of the materials from production, to bottling locations, to sourcing the water location, to the warehouse distribution or supermarket warehouse and then to their stores, finally to the consumer.

Weight – a glass bottle is 40 times heavier (based on 500ml bottles) than a plastic bottle, which impacts shipping costs, vehicle wear and tear, fuel costs and increase in emissions.

Disposal – irrespective of where your bottle or can is “left” – landfill, recycling, the countryside, or waterways they all have an impact on pollution and contamination, or the time it takes to decompose. Non more polluting than plastic.

The UK is getting better on recycling but the impact from cradle to grave is still a risk to the environment and further contamination to our environment. If you don’t like the taste of tap water then the solution if to dispense your individual mineralised water from the LUQEL Water Station.

Possible Contaminants Microplastics Glass Alumnium metal shards
Time to decompose 450+ years, longer in a landfill 1 million years 200-500 years
How many times to recycle Must be downcycled Endlessly Endlessly
Challenges
  • Plastic is petroleum-based – which can result in oil spills and contamination of soils and water
  • Plastic emits carbon dioxide
  • Factories producing plastic run on fossil fuels
  • 9% of plastic is actually recycled
  • Plastic can only be downcycled, so it becomes an item of lesser quality
  • Leech toxic chemicals into the environment over time
  • Never breaks down, becomes microplastics
  • Plastic bottle production release more greenhouse gas emissions than over a million cars on the road
  • New glass needs sand (sourced from river and sea beds) – large impact on the ecosystem
  • 33% of glass is actually recycled
  • Risk of damage in transportation
  • Furnaces used to create glass run on fossil fuel
  • Separating and identifying aluminium from steel, plastic and other debris
  • Quality breaks down as it is continually recycled
  • Energy costs in reprocessing and transporting materials
  • Sourced from Jamaica, West Africa, Australia and South America as bauxite
  • Production factories use fossil fuels in the production phase
Opportunities
  • No chemical interaction – contents remain as bottled
  • Using green glass instead of clear reduces the CO2 emissions by 20%, but consumers don’t trust water that isn’t in a clear bottle
  • High market value, makes economic incentive for individuals and businesses to recycle
  • Recycling aluminium saves 95% of the energy needed to make new cans

LUQEL

LUQEL is a pioneer in water technology, its’ mission is to radically change the way people drink water to make a lasting difference. Visionary innovations make plastic superfluous. With our perfect purification process, individual mineralisation, ‘smart’ bottles and the digitalised eco-system, our products turn tap water into a whole new level of water enjoyment, “Water as individual as you are”.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!